The Olive Oil Controversy: Unveiling the Truth Behind Your Kitchen Staple

Share this blog

In recent years, the quality and authenticity of olive oil have come under scrutiny, with shocking revelations about widespread fraud in the industry. A groundbreaking episode of the popular news program “60 Minutes” shed light on this issue, exposing a disturbing trend of adulteration in many well-known olive oil brands

The “60 Minutes” Investigation

The “60 Minutes” team delved deep into the world of olive oil production, particularly focusing on Italy, where the problem is especially prevalent. They discovered that a significant portion of olive oil labeled as “extra virgin” and “100% Italian” was, in fact, far from it

The investigation revealed that many popular brands were selling products that were actually mixtures of low-quality olive oils or even cheap seed oils with added dyes and flavorings to mimic the characteristics of genuine extra virgin olive oil

Brands That Failed the Test

According to the report, several well-known brands failed to meet the standards for extra virgin olive oil. These included:

• Bertolli
• Felippo Berio
• Mazola
• Pompeian
• Primadonna
• Carapelli
• Coricelli
• Mezzetta
• Star
• Sasso
• Colavita
• Whole Foods
• Antica Badia
• Safeway

The 6 most common additives found in seed oils

Seed oils often contain various additives to improve their stability, shelf life, and appearance. The most common additives found in seed oils include:

Antioxidants

Synthetic antioxidants are frequently added to seed oils to prevent oxidative damage and extend shelf life. The most common synthetic antioxidants include:

• BHA (butylated hydroxyanisole)
• BHT (butylated hydroxytoluene)
• TBHQ (tertbutyl hydroquinone)

These synthetic antioxidants have been classified as potential carcinogens and are banned as additives in some countries

Solvents

Hexane is a petroleum-based solvent commonly used in the extraction process of seed oils. While most of the hexane is supposed to evaporate during processing, trace amounts may remain in the final product

Other Additives

• Citric acid: Used to “wash” the oil and remove unwanted compounds
• Bleaching clay: Added to remove unwanted compounds and improve color

Natural Additives

Some manufacturers are exploring the use of natural additives to improve oil quality:

• Gallic acid
• Rutin
• β-carotene
• Olive leaf extract

These natural additives may help stabilize the oils and provide antioxidant properties without the potential health risks associated with synthetic additives.It’s important to note that the presence and amounts of these additives can vary depending on the specific oil and manufacturing process. Consumers concerned about additives may want to choose cold-pressed or unrefined oils, which typically undergo less processing and contain fewer additives.

A Surprising Winner

Interestingly, amidst the sea of failed brands, Kirkland Organic emerged as one of the few that passed the test and was certified as genuine extra virgin olive oil

The Seed Oil Connection

The revelation that some “olive oils” contain cheap seed oils brings us to another controversial topic in the world of cooking oils: the debate over seed oils themselves.

The Seed Oil Debate

In recent years, seed oils have been the subject of intense debate in nutrition circles. Some claim they are harmful to health, while others argue they can be part of a healthy diet

The Case Against Seed Oils

Critics argue that seed oils are:

1. High in omega-6 fatty acids, which may promote inflammation when consumed in excess
2. Often highly processed, potentially losing beneficial compounds during refinement
3. Unstable at high temperatures, potentially forming harmful compounds when used for cooking

The Case for Seed Oils

On the other hand, proponents and many nutrition experts argue that:

1. Seed oils are rich in polyunsaturated fats, which can help lower bad cholesterol levels
2. They can be part of a healthy diet when used in moderation and as part of a balanced eating plan
3. Replacing saturated fats with unsaturated fats found in seed oils can reduce the risk of heart disease

How omega-6 fatty acids in seed oils impact overall health

The impact of omega-6 fatty acids from seed oils on overall health has been a subject of debate in the scientific community. While some concerns have been raised, current research generally supports the health benefits of moderate omega-6 consumption.

Cardiovascular Health

Omega-6 fatty acids, particularly linoleic acid (LA), have shown positive effects on cardiovascular health:

• Higher intake of omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) is associated with a lower risk of stroke, heart disease, and early death
• Replacing saturated fats with omega-6 fats reduced the risk of heart attacks and other coronary events by 24% in a meta-analysis of six randomized trials
• Longitudinal studies demonstrate that moderate intake of LA is linked to a lower risk of cardiovascular diseases, likely due to its cholesterol-lowering effects

However, some conflicting evidence exists:

• A Mendelian randomization analysis suggested that higher serum levels of arachidonic acid (AA), an omega-6 fatty acid, might increase the risk of coronary heart disease, myocardial infarction, and large artery stroke

Inflammation and Chronic Diseases

The relationship between omega-6 fatty acids and inflammation is complex:

• Contrary to previous beliefs, the American Heart Association found that increased omega-6 consumption either reduced markers of inflammation or left them unchanged
• Some studies suggest that omega-6 fatty acids may regulate antioxidant signaling pathways and modulate inflammatory processes
• However, the Arthritis Foundation notes that omega-6 fatty acids may trigger the production of pro-inflammatory substances, potentially worsening symptoms in people with arthritis

Metabolic Effects

Omega-6 fatty acids influence various metabolic factors:

• Higher levels of arachidonic acid were associated with increased fasting blood glucose and LDL cholesterol levels, but also with higher HDL cholesterol and lower triglycerides
• Replacing saturated fats with omega-6 PUFAs has been shown to lower total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, and the total cholesterol to HDL cholesterol ratio

Other Health Considerations

• Omega-6 fatty acids play a role in brain development, and their deficiency may contribute to various health issues, including dermatitis, renal hypertension, and decreased body resistance to infection
• Increasing intake of arachidonic acid (up to 1500 mg/day) may benefit muscle and cognitive performance without adverse effects on platelet aggregation, blood clotting, or immune function

Conclusion

While the evidence is mixed, current research generally supports the health benefits of moderate omega-6 consumption. The key lies in maintaining a balance between omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids and consuming them as part of a varied, whole-food-based diet. As with all fats, moderation is crucial, as excessive intake can lead to an imbalance in calorie consumption

It’s important to note that more research is needed to fully elucidate the effects of omega-6 PUFAs on cardiometabolic outcomes, as some studies have shown heterogeneous results

The Bottom Line

While the olive oil scandal highlights the need for greater transparency and regulation in the food industry, it’s important to approach the seed oil debate with nuance. The key lies in moderation and context

When it comes to olive oil, look for reputable brands and certifications. For seed oils, consider their place in your overall diet. Used in moderation for home cooking, they can be part of a healthy eating pattern

Insiders Health Tip

Remember, the most significant impact on your health comes from your overall dietary pattern, not from single ingredients. Focus on a diet rich in whole foods, including a variety of fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains, and you’ll be on the right track to good health.

References:

https://www.massgeneral.org/news/article/seed-oils-facts-myths

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7520389/

https://www.levels.com/blog/the-ultimate-guide-to-seed-oils-and-metabolic-health

https://denversportsandholisticmedicine.com/blog/the-ugly-truth-about-seed-oils-and-5-healthy-alternatives

8 Toxic Seed Oils and What to Know